How to use this refinance calculator

Enter what you owe today: your current balance, your current rate, and the principal-and-interest part of your current monthly payment — not the full bill if yours also collects tax and insurance. Then enter the offer you are comparing: the new rate, the new term in years, and the closing costs. Results update as you type — the new payment, the monthly saving, the break-even point, and the total cost of both loans side by side. The Download Summary button saves the comparison as a text file.

The two numbers that decide whether refinancing pays

Quick answer: A refinance pays when (1) you will keep the new loan past the break-even point — closing costs ÷ monthly saving — and (2) the new loan's total cost, payments plus closing costs, is lower than what your current loan will still cost you. A lower monthly payment alone proves nothing.

This calculator runs both tests. It simulates your current loan month by month at the payment you enter to find how many months are really left and what they will cost, then prices the new loan with the standard amortization formula on the same balance. Property tax, insurance and PMI are left out on purpose: they continue either way, so they cannot change which loan wins.

How the break-even point works

Closing costs are the price of switching, and the break-even is how long the monthly saving takes to repay that price: closing costs ÷ monthly saving. If the answer is 21 months and you expect to move within a year, the switch loses money even at a lower rate. Stay put for a decade, and a break-even of two or three years can still be well worth it. Break-even is a necessary test, but not a sufficient one — it says nothing about total interest, where the trap further down sits.

Worked example: a refinance that genuinely pays

You owe $300,000 at 7%, paying $1,995.91 a month with the full 30 years still to run. A lender offers 5.5% over a new 30-year term with $6,000 of closing costs:

Keep current loanRefinance at 5.5%
Monthly payment$1,995.91$1,703.37
Months of payments360360
Total interest$418,524.53$313,212.12
Closing costs—$6,000.00
Total cost$718,524.53$619,212.12

The payment falls by $292.54 a month, the closing costs are recovered after about 21 months, and the new loan costs $99,312.41 less overall. Both tests pass — that is the shape of a refinance that works. The same loan maths drives our Mortgage Calculator and Loan Calculator.

The longer-term trap: a lower payment that costs more

Now change one thing: suppose that same $300,000 at 7% has only 15 years left to run, so your payment is $2,696.48. Refinance into a fresh 30-year loan at the same 5.5% and the payment drops by $993.11 a month — which feels like a triumph. But you have swapped 15 remaining years of payments for 30 new ones: the new loan's total cost is the same $619,212.12 as above, against $485,367.93 to simply finish the current loan. The "saving" costs you $133,844.19. Nothing about the rate was dishonest; the term did the damage — which is why the results above always show total cost both ways.

When refinancing usually pays — and when it doesn't

Refinancing tends to pay when the new rate is meaningfully lower, the balance is large, you will keep the loan well past break-even, and the new term is no longer than the time you have left. It tends to disappoint when the balance is small, when you may move soon, when closing costs are high relative to the rate drop, or when a longer term is doing most of the payment reduction. If a lender quotes you a payment, run their rate and term here before you sign.

Common mistakes when judging a refinance

  • Comparing payments instead of totals. A payment can fall because the rate dropped or because the term stretched. Only the total-cost lines separate the two.
  • Double-counting closing costs. Paid in cash, they belong in the closing-costs field. Rolled into the new loan, they belong in the balance instead. Never both.
  • Entering the full escrowed payment. Tax and insurance continue unchanged either way; enter only the principal-and-interest part, or the months-left figure comes out too short.
  • Trusting the "1% rule". The old rule ignores your balance, your costs and how long you will stay. Break-even plus total cost is the real test.

Estimates, not an offer — and your numbers stay yours

These figures are estimates for planning, not a lender quote, an offer of credit, or financial advice: your actual rate, costs and payment come from the lender's Loan Estimate and depend on your credit and property. The calculation runs entirely in your browser — no balance or rate you type is uploaded, tracked or stored. The only lasting copy is the summary you choose to download.